In most years, securing a No. 1 seed in the NCAA Tournament would be a cause for celebration. It is, after all, the highest honor the selection committee can bestow upon a team before the madness of March truly begins.
However, this year’s bracket leaves USC head coach Lindsay Gottlieb and a significant portion of the college basketball world puzzled. Instead of feeling validated, she felt slighted, an unusual sentiment for a coach leading a top-seeded team.
Lindsay Gottlieb’s Selection Controversy Leaves USC Feeling Slighted
Following the regular season and conference tournaments, the NCAA Selection Committee awarded four No. 1 seeds: UCLA, Texas, South Carolina, and USC.
On the surface, the Trojans’ inclusion among the nation’s top teams should have been met with enthusiasm. But upon closer inspection, the placement and rankings within the top four raised concerns, particularly for USC’s head coach.
Coach Lindsay Gottlieb did not shy away from expressing her frustration regarding the selection process.
Speaking with reporters after the bracket reveal, she bluntly expressed her dissatisfaction. As quoted by Ryan Kartje of the LA Times, Gottlieb stated, “I never thought I’d be a one-seed and feel disrespected.”
Her remarks reflected a deeper issue with how the selection committee weighs various factors when determining seedings.
While every No. 1 seed technically has an equal shot at making the Final Four, a team’s specific placement within the bracket can significantly impact its path.
Gottlieb further questioned the rationale behind some of the committee’s decisions.
“Sometimes I don’t understand the people who make decisions in women’s college basketball and why they do what they do.”
This candid admission highlighted the confusion surrounding the final rankings, particularly when examining how USC compared to the other No. 1 seeds.
The Debate Over the Selection Process
The controversy largely stemmed from the committee’s decision to give UCLA the overall No. 1 seed despite the Bruins suffering two losses to USC during the season.
In the eyes of the selection committee, UCLA still ranked as the best team in the nation, followed closely by Texas and South Carolina. This left USC as the fourth No. 1 seed, which, in practical terms, meant a more challenging overall tournament path for the Trojans.
At the heart of Gottlieb’s frustration was the inconsistency in how the selection committee weighed different aspects of a team’s resume. While overall records and strength of schedule play a role, it became evident that recency bias had a significant impact.
USC lost to UCLA just a week before Selection Sunday, and that head-to-head result seemingly carried more weight than their season-long body of work.
WHO WILL THE RIVAL UCLA BRUINS PLAY? A LOOK AT EVERY BIG TEN MATCHUP IN WOMEN’S MARCH MADNESS
The selection process has long been a point of contention in both the men’s and women’s tournaments.
While logic and rankings suggest certain teams should be placed in specific positions, subjective decisions made by the committee can sometimes defy expectations. This year, USC found itself on the receiving end of those questionable choices.
While Gottlieb’s frustration is understandable, the only way for USC to silence doubters is by proving itself on the court. The Trojans must now use their perceived slight as motivation. If they fail to make a deep tournament run, the frustration of overseeding will quickly become an afterthought, overshadowed by results on the court.
Ultimately, selection committee decisions are beyond a team’s control. What remains within USC’s grasp is its ability to fight through a challenging bracket and show that it belongs among the elite. If they don’t at least win their region, this seeding controversy will serve as a painful reminder of a missed opportunity.
The Trojans will open NCAA Tournament play against the No. 16 seed UNC Greensboro on Saturday.
Don’t miss a moment of March Madness! Download your 2025 NCAA Tournament printable bracket and stay on top of every game, matchup, and Cinderella story. Get yours now!
