The 2025 NFL Draft quarterback class is drawing mixed reactions, but one surprising name is starting to gain steam: Tyler Shough. While most mock drafts feature more consistent names like Miami (FL) Hurricanes’ Cam Ward, one current head coach has gone against the grain, publicly stating that Shough is the best QB in this year’s class.
That hot take has caused a stir among college football fans and draft analysts. The CFB world is striking back, pointing to a long list of red flags in Shough’s resume, including injury history, age, and inconsistency.
Tyler Shough’s 7-Year College Journey Raises Eyebrows
Now 25 years old, Shough started his college career in 2018 as part of the same recruiting class as Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields, who are already seasoned NFL quarterbacks. After serving as a backup to Justin Herbert at Oregon, Shough transferred to Texas Tech, where he struggled to stay healthy. In three years in Lubbock, he played just 15 games, throwing for 2,922 yards, 23 touchdowns, and 11 interceptions.
Following the 2023 season, Shough transferred again, this time to Louisville. He finally started every game in a season, passing for 3,195 yards, 23 touchdowns, and just six interceptions with a solid 62.7% completion rate. Despite this breakout, critics still question his NFL upside due to his lengthy injury history and late development.
A viral tweet summed up what many in the football community are thinking:
Someone needs to help me out with this Tyler Shough Draft allure.
A 25-year old quarterback who has been injured just about every season of his seven-year college career, and was never quite consistent at any point.
Is all of a sudden a possible first round pick? He possesses…
— CJ Vogel (@CJVogel_OTF) April 18, 2025
Analysts echo that reaction, pointing out that while Shough has great size and leadership traits, his lengthy college career and inconsistent production make him a risky investment.
Meanwhile, Cam Ward continues to fly under the radar, despite steadily improving every season. Coming from a Wing-T high school offense, Ward made massive strides in college, showing a unique ability to read defenses, create plays under pressure, and deliver accurate throws off-platform.
He doesn’t have elite athleticism or a rocket arm, but Ward’s greatest asset is his awareness. He sees windows before they open and keeps plays alive with brilliant footwork. Critics say he can hold onto the ball too long or avoid check-downs, but his overall upside feels more dependable than Shough’s.
KEEP READING: Tyler Shough Draft Projection: Potential NFL Landings Spots for Louisville QB
The New York Giants recently held a private workout with Shough, signaling serious interest. While he’s not projected as a Day 1 pick, the growing buzz could elevate him into late second or third-round consideration.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in football, men’s basketball, women’s basketball, and baseball!
