March Madness has produced some of the most thrilling moments in college basketball history. However, not all of them have been free from controversy. Questionable officiating, disputed calls, and controversial finishes have often left fans and players in disbelief.
Top 10 NCAA Tournament Games That Sparked Major Controversy
10. Georgetown vs. Princeton (1989, First Round)
A 16-seed had never beaten a No. 1 seed until 2018, but Princeton came close in 1989. Georgetown’s Alonzo Mourning blocked Kit Mueller’s potential game-winning shot with one second left, securing a 50-49 win. Many believed Mourning fouled Mueller.
“I thought maybe he hit my hand. I don’t know,” Mueller said.
9. Indiana vs. Syracuse (1987, National Championship)
Keith Smart’s legendary game-winner with five seconds left overshadowed Syracuse’s controversial timeout request. The clock inexplicably dropped from five to one second before Syracuse was granted a timeout.
“I thought we called [the timeout], but they didn’t see it,” coach Jim Boeheim said after the 74-73 loss.
8. Purdue vs. Tennessee (2019, Sweet 16)
Carsen Edwards was awarded three free throws after Tennessee’s Lamonte Turner was called for a foul with 1.7 seconds left. Edwards made two, sending the game to overtime, where Purdue won 99-94. Though Tennessee’s Rick Barnes later admitted,
“It was a foul.”
7. SMU vs. UCLA (2015, First Round)
SMU led late when Bryce Alford’s three-pointer was called goaltending against Yanick Moreira. The replay suggested the ball wasn’t close to the cylinder, but the ruling stood. UCLA won 60-59.
“I don’t know if it would have gone in or not, but he definitely grabbed it on the way,” Alford said postgame.
6. Arizona vs. Kentucky (1997, National Championship)
Arizona won its first title in overtime, defeating Kentucky 84-79, but not without controversy. Arizona set a tournament record with 34 made free throws on 41 attempts. Kentucky, by contrast, shot only 17 free throws, leading to accusations of biased officiating.
5. Duke vs. Indiana (2002, Sweet 16)
Duke’s Jay Williams missed a crucial free throw in the final seconds, but Carlos Boozer grabbed the rebound and appeared to be fouled on his putback attempt. No whistle was blown, and the Hoosiers escaped with a 74-73 victory. Coach Mike Krzyzewski refused to blame the refs, stating,
“The game is too good to reduce it to excuses.”
4. Duke vs. Wisconsin (2015, National Championship)
With under two minutes left, Bronson Koenig’s missed layup led to a controversial out-of-bounds call. Replays appeared to show Duke’s Justise Winslow had touched the ball, but officials awarded possession to Duke. NCAA officiating head John Adams later admitted the refs never saw the angle fans viewed on TV.
3. Michigan vs. North Carolina (1993, National Championship)
Chris Webber’s infamous “timeout” sealed Michigan’s fate. With 11 seconds left, Webber secured a rebound but traveled. He then called a timeout Michigan didn’t have, resulting in a technical foul. North Carolina made its free throws and won 77-71. “The Timeout” remains one of the tournament’s most infamous blunders.
KEEP READING: March Madness Fun Facts: Surprising Stats and Records You Need To Know
2. Purdue vs. Tennessee (2019, Sweet 16)
With Purdue down two in the final seconds, Lamonte Turner was called for a controversial foul on Carsen Edwards’ 3-point attempt. Replays suggested minimal contact. Edwards hit two free throws, forcing overtime, where Purdue won 99-94. Fans questioned whether the foul should have been called in such a crucial moment.
1. Seton Hall vs. Michigan (1989, National Championship)
In overtime, Seton Hall led 79-78 when Gerald Green was whistled for a questionable foul on Rumeal Robinson. Robinson hit both free throws, giving Michigan an 80-79 victory and its first championship.
“I honestly feel if I was the referee, I probably wouldn’t have called that,” Robinson admitted postgame.
Don’t miss a moment of March Madness! Download your 2025 NCAA Tournament printable bracket and stay on top of every game, matchup, and Cinderella story. Get yours now!
