In the world of college basketball, eligibility decisions can change the course of a season-and sometimes spark a firestorm. Louisville’s hopes for a dominant frontcourt in 2025-26 now hang in the balance after a controversial NCAA ruling on one of their most promising players.
NCAA Denies Aly Khalifa’s Eligibility, Louisville Appeals
Louisville center Aly Khalifa, a transfer from BYU who redshirted last season while rehabbing a knee injury, has been ruled ineligible for the 2025-26 season by the NCAA. The university announced Thursday that Khalifa’s request for an extension of his five-year eligibility clock was denied, effectively barring him from using his fourth and final season of college basketball.
Louisville big man Aly Khalifa, who redshirted last season, has seen his eligibility waiver denied by the NCAA. The school is appealing. Their full statement: pic.twitter.com/DrSuXMCwPG
— Jeff Borzello (@jeffborzello) May 15, 2025
Louisville is appealing the decision, maintaining that Khalifa has a strong case for an additional year, especially given his medical circumstances and academic progress toward a master’s degree.
Khalifa, originally from Egypt, has established himself as one of the nation’s best passing big men. In his most recent season at BYU, he averaged 5.7 points, 3.7 rebounds, and 4.0 assists per game, boasting a 3.59 assist-to-turnover ratio-seventh-best in Division I.
His sophomore year at Charlotte saw him post career highs of 11.7 points and 6.3 rebounds per game. Despite sitting out last season, Khalifa dedicated himself to recovery and conditioning, dropping nearly 50 pounds in preparation for a return to the court.
The timing of the NCAA’s decision has left Louisville’s roster in a precarious position. With another center, James Scott, entering the transfer portal, the Cardinals are down to just two true big men- one recovering from an ACL tear and another new to the American college game.
Head coach Pat Kelsey has repeatedly called Khalifa the “best passing big man in the country,” underscoring the impact of this loss on the team’s outlook.
Fans and Analysts Sound Off
The NCAA’s decision regarding Aly Khalifa has triggered a passionate response from the college basketball community. Fans have taken to social media to express their frustration, with many calling the ruling unfair and urging the organization to reconsider.
One user captured the prevailing sentiment with the straightforward plea, “Booooooo. Let him play,” reflecting the widespread disappointment among supporters who believe Khalifa deserves another shot on the court.
Booooooo. Let him play
— Ethan (@EthanHoliday2) May 15, 2025
Analysts and experts have also weighed in, amplifying the criticism. An ESPN analyst described the NCAA’s move as “ridiculous,” highlighting that Khalifa missed the entire season due to a legitimate injury and followed all proper procedures.
One fan expressed frustration, asking, “Why would a guy who played three seasons not be eligible for a fourth after sitting out due to injury, while others play six or seven seasons?” They also questioned, “Does this happen anywhere else in the country?”
These comments highlight perceived inconsistencies in NCAA rules and concerns about fairness, especially since Khalifa redshirted the 2024-25 season for injury rehab yet was denied an eligibility extension, fueling debates over transparency in the decision-making process.
Fans and folks in the sports world are pretty frustrated right now, and it really shows just how unhappy people are with the NCAA’s rules about who gets to play.
KEEP READING: March Madness Fans Roast ESPN’s 2025-26 Top 25 Drop
A lot of people think Khalifa’s situation is a perfect example of bigger problems in the system-like how confusing and sometimes unfair the process can be. These decisions don’t just affect one player, either; they can really shake things up for student-athletes and their whole teams.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!
