True freshmen have occasionally shocked the college football world, delivering performances well beyond their years and expectations, stamping their legacies in just one season.
Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith is the latest name to take center stage, and his remarkable freshman season has sparked a compelling question: Is he the greatest true freshman in college football history?
Jeremiah Smith Makes His Case For Greatest True Freshman In College Football History
When discussing the best true freshmen in the sport’s history, top names that come to mind: Herschel Walker and Adrian Peterson.
Walker’s legendary 1980 season at Georgia redefined what a freshman could achieve, rushing for 1,616 yards and 15 touchdowns while leading the Bulldogs to a national championship.
Similarly, Peterson burst onto the scene at Oklahoma in 2004, rushing for 1,925 yards and finishing second in Heisman Trophy voting — a feat no true freshman has matched since.
Yet, Smith’s skill set — elite speed, precise route running, and exceptional hands — sets him apart. At just 19 years old, Smith has amassed over 1,000 receiving yards and double-digit touchdowns this season, positioning himself as one of the nation’s top receivers and the cornerstone of Ohio State’s pursuit of a national championship.
Smith has made a strong case for himself as the best freshman of all time, particularly among wide receivers. Rarely has a player at his position possessed such a complete skill set at such a young age. Smith combines his extensive repertoire to terrorize opposing defenses.
He isn’t just a deep threat — he’s a versatile weapon who can win at every level of the field. Whether it’s high-pointing a contested catch, beating defenders with precise footwork, or outrunning secondaries, Smith has already proven he belongs among college football’s upper echelon.
Statistically, Smith’s numbers are impressive as well. In his first season at Ohio State, his aforementioned 1,000+ receiving yards and double-digit touchdowns are rare for any wide receiver, but for a true freshman, they’re nearly unprecedented.
Smith’s production has come against top-tier competition in the Big Ten, further solidifying his case as one of the best young players in college football history.
Still, can Smith’s accomplishments truly compare to the likes of guys like Walker and Peterson? Herschel Walker carried an entire offense as a freshman, bulldozing SEC defenses week after week en route to a national championship.
Peterson’s dominance at Oklahoma was unparalleled, as his blend of size, speed, and vision made him unstoppable.
Where Smith separates himself is in his positional rarity. Running backs like Walker and Peterson have historically been able to make immediate impacts due to the simplicity of their role in most offenses. Wide receivers, on the other hand, face a steeper learning curve.
They must master route trees, adjust to defensive schemes, and build chemistry with their quarterback — all challenges that typically take years to perfect. Yet Smith has excelled, becoming the focal point of Ohio State’s offense from Day 1.
While Smith’s freshman season is extraordinary, surpassing legends like Walker and Peterson is no small feat. Walker’s national title and Peterson’s record-breaking rushing totals still loom large.
However, Smith’s rare talent and immediate impact at wide receiver make him a unique case.
If his freshman season is any indication, Jeremiah Smith is on track to build a legacy that rivals the greatest players in college football history — and perhaps even claim the crown as the best true freshman to ever play the game.
College Football Network has you covered with the latest from the ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, SEC, and every Group of Five conference and FBS Independent program.