Ohio State Buckeyes safety Caleb Downs has already cemented himself as one of the most impressive defensive players in college football, but after securing a top position on on3 senior writer Ari Wasserman’s list of returning college football players, his claim to the title just got more solid. As he enters his junior season in 2025, it is to be seen if he can stay true to his reputation.
Caleb Downs on the Path To Becoming Best Defensive Player in College Football
Caleb Downs has been nothing short of dominant since transferring from the Alabama Crimson Tide to the Ohio State Buckeyes. His versatility allows him to thrive in multiple roles, whether it be patrolling the deep secondary, stacking the box, or locking down elite receivers.
In 2024, Downs racked up 71 total tackles, six pass deflections, and an interception, proving his ability to impact the game at every level. His performance against top-tier offenses, including a crucial three-pass breakup outing against Oregon, further showcased his elite instincts and playmaking prowess.
After seeing his performance and gauging his potential as one of the best players to ever grace the defense role for the Buckeyes, Wasserman placed Downs in the second position on his list of top 10 returning college football players.
Beyond his statistical production, Downs gained national attention for his ability to adapt and excel in defensive coordinator Jim Knowles’ unit. Initially utilized as a traditional safety, he has since evolved into a dynamic chess piece capable of making plays all over the field.
Whether it’s stopping the run, blitzing the quarterback, or covering deep threats, Downs has demonstrated the rare ability to execute at an elite level in any situation. His physicality, football IQ, and natural instincts make him a nightmare for opposing offenses.
How Caleb Downs Can Become The Country’s Defensive Player
If Downs increases his interception totals and continues to make impact plays in high-stakes moments, he could solidify himself as a frontrunner for prestigious defensive awards and a high draft position in the NFL Draft when he chooses to declare.
Ohio State’s defensive scheme will be a key factor in Downs’ continued success. Knowles has already showcased his creativity in utilizing Downs in different roles, and further innovation could unlock even greater potential.
KEEP READING: Caleb Downs Gets Real on Nick Saban’s Retirement Before Making His Ohio State Move
However, Knowles will be heading up the Penn State defense. The safety will need to show even more adaptability under a new defensive coordinator to finish strong.
NFL scouts are already eyeing Downs as a potential top draft pick in 2026 if he declares then, and a dominant junior campaign would only bolster his case. If he continues his upward trajectory, Downs may not only become the best defender in 2025 but also solidify himself as a generational talent.
College Football Network has you covered with the latest from the ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, SEC, and every Group of Five conference and FBS Independent program.
