Oklahoma’s 2025 season carries massive stakes, and no player embodies that pressure more than QB transfer John Mateer. After a breakout campaign at Washington State, he now finds himself at the helm of the Sooners’ offense and the lone representative from Oklahoma on CSN’s Top 100 Returning Players list.
His dynamic playmaking ability made him a star in the Pac-12, but can he replicate that success in the SEC? With Oklahoma still struggling to find its footing in its new conference, Mateer’s performance could determine not just the team’s fate, but also head coach Brent Venables’ future.
John Mateer Ranks Among Top 100 Returning Players
John Mateer’s electric 2024 season put him on the national radar, as he tallied 3,139 passing yards, 29 touchdowns, and 44 total scores for the Washington State Cougars.
His ability to create plays outside of structure and his strong arm made him one of the most acclaimed quarterbacks in college football, securing his position as the lone Oklahoma player in CSN’s Top 100 Returning Players list.
Now, he reunites with offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle in Norman, bringing both hope and a little criticism. Questions surrounded Mateer’s transfer to Oklahoma, particularly his ability to transition to SEC competition.
However, analysts like Jay Smith from the “Locked on Sooners” podcast remain optimistic. On the February 19th episode, Smith highlighted Mateer’s impressive numbers against quality opponents like Washington, Oregon, and Boise State.
“If you don’t think that’s going to translate, then you obviously didn’t watch Cam Ward play,” Smith argued, referencing another underappreciated QB who thrived after transferring to a bigger stage.
For Oklahoma, the stakes couldn’t be higher. Following a disappointing 6-7 season, the Sooners lost 29 players to the transfer portal. Venables responded by bringing in 15 newcomers, including Mateer, to rebuild. His $44.8 million buyout looms over the program, making 2025 a make-or-break season.
Mateer’s prior success under Arbuckle provides hope for a smooth transition. His mobility, creativity, and familiarity with the system could give Oklahoma an edge in an unforgiving SEC landscape.
WHO ELSE MADE THE LIST? READ IT HERE
However, last season exposed the conference’s brutal scheduling disparities, with Oklahoma facing far tougher opponents than Texas. Venables’ job security might be in jeopardy if the Sooners struggle again.
With Oklahoma desperate for stability, Mateer isn’t just the lone Sooner on the Top 100 list; he’s their best chance at redemption.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in football, basketball, and more!
