College football is filled with stories of young stars ascending to the absolute pinnacle of their careers, but that isn’t the case for everyone. Some of its brightest talents have seen their careers tragically cut short by devastating injuries.
Here, we rank the top 10 college football stars whose careers ended prematurely, including Utah’s Cam Rising, whose recent retirement surprised many in the sport.
Notable College Football Stars to Have Their Careers Cut Short
RB Marcus Lattimore, South Carolina (2010-12)
Marcus Lattimore burst onto the scene as a freshman phenom, rushing for 1,197 yards and 17 touchdowns in 2010. His sophomore year was cut short by a torn knee ligament against Mississippi State, and a dislocated knee in 2012 ended his junior season.
His exceptional talent made him a projected first-round NFL draft pick, but his injuries tragically derailed a potential Hall of Fame trajectory.
QB Cam Rising, Utah (2019-24; Texas 2018)
Cam Rising guided Utah to consecutive Pac-12 titles in 2021 and 2022, throwing for 46 touchdowns and earning first-team All-Pac-12 honors. However, a knee injury sidelined him for the 2023 season, and a hand injury in 2024 forced his medical retirement at age 25.
“Orthopedic physicians told me I’ll never play again,” Rising announced on X, concluding a career that spanned 30 games and 28 starts.
WR Tyrone Prothro, Alabama (2003-05)
Tyrone Prothro’s remarkable 2005 catch against Southern Mississippi remains one of college football’s most memorable moments.
But weeks later, a horrific leg injury against Florida shattered his tibia and fibula. Despite undergoing 11 surgeries, Prothro’s leg never fully recovered. With 58 catches for 853 yards and exceptional return skills, Prothro was on the cusp of stardom before the injury ended his junior season.
RB Jahvid Best, California (2007-09)
Jahvid Best was an electrifying performer. As a California sophomore in 2008, he rushed for 1,580 yards and 15 touchdowns, averaging an impressive 8.1 yards per carry. A diving end zone attempt against Oregon State in 2009 resulted in a severe concussion after he landed on his head.
He entered the NFL draft but was limited to two seasons with the Detroit Lions due to concussions. Best later competed in the 2016 Olympics as a track athlete.
DT Eric LeGrand, Rutgers (2008-10)
Eric LeGrand was a promising defensive tackle at Rutgers, recording 33 tackles and 7.5 tackles for loss as a sophomore in 2009.
In 2010, a spinal cord injury during a kickoff return against Army left him paralyzed from the neck down. His No. 52 is the only retired jersey at Rutgers, and he remains an inspirational figure for the Scarlet Knights program.
DB Chucky Mullins, Mississippi (1988-89)
Chucky Mullins’ head-first tackle against Vanderbilt in 1989 during Mississippi’s homecoming game left him paralyzed from the neck down. The defensive back, known for his tenacious spirit, died in 1991 from a pulmonary embolism.
He was later honored by having his No. ’38’ retired by the team, and with a statue in Vaught-Hemingway Stadium. Mullins’ injury deeply affected the college football community and remains a somber moment in the sport’s history. Today, the number has been un-retired and is given to the annual winner of the “Chucky Mullins Memorial Courage Award.”
S Devon Walker, Tulane (2009-12)
Devon Walker, a Tulane safety, was paralyzed from the neck down after a collision with a teammate during a 2012 game against Tulsa.
With 23 tackles in 2011, he was emerging as a key defender for the Green Wave. The New Orleans Saints signed him in 2016 as a symbolic gesture, recognizing his resilience despite his career-ending injury. Since then, Tulane Athletics has retired his Number ’18’ across all sports.
RB Willis McGahee, Miami (2000-02)
Willis McGahee’s 2002 season at Miami was record-breaking, with 1,753 rushing yards and 28 touchdowns.
In the 2003 BCS National Championship game, Ohio State’s Will Allen delivered a hit to McGahee’s knee, tearing his anterior cruciate ligament, medial collateral ligament, and posterior cruciate ligament. Despite a solid NFL career with over 8,000 rushing yards, his college stardom was cut short, and injuries limited his professional potential.
LB Chris Borland, Wisconsin (2009-13)
Chris Borland earned Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year honors in 2013, recording 112 tackles for the Wisconsin Badgers. Drafted by the San Francisco 49ers in 2014, he retired after an outstanding rookie season due to concerns about concussions sustained in college.
“I was worried about my longevity in life,” Borland told ESPN. His 107 tackles and two interceptions as an NFL rookie highlighted his potential, but head injuries forced an early retirement.
WR Dante Love, Ball State (2005-08)
Dante Love led the nation in receiving in 2007, with 100 catches for 1,398 yards at Ball State.
In 2008, a broken neck injury during a game against Indiana silenced the stadium. Doctors ruled out any possibility of him playing football again, and he finished his college career with 199 receptions and 20 touchdowns, a small-school star whose NFL aspirations were tragically ended.
KEEP READING: Top 10 WRs in College Football History — Larry Fitzgerald and Randy Moss Make the List
These 10 stars, from Lattimore’s knee injuries to Rising’s hand surgery, underscore the delicate nature of athletic careers. Their stories resonate beyond mere statistics, demonstrating remarkable resilience in the face of profound disappointment.
Even as college football evolves with improved medical protocols, the inherent risk of career-ending injuries remains a stark reality.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!
