The 2026 NFL Draft is already making headlines, even though the 2025 draft just wrapped up. One name dominating early conversations is Arch Manning, the rising star quarterback from the Texas Longhorns. Many analysts already see him as the clear-cut No. 1 pick.
But for now, he is keeping his focus on the present. His eyes are set on leading the Longhorns into a high-stakes college season. There are high expectations, and several insiders believe the Longhorns could finish with an impressive 11-1 record, earning another shot at the College Football Playoff.
Meanwhile, a surprise quarterback transfer has raised questions about Manning’s readiness to take the lead and whether he’s fully prepared to guide the team to those high expectations.
Texas Goes 11-1? Insiders’ Bold Predictions, Transfer QB Move Spark Big Questions About Arch Manning’s Future
Texas football is gearing up for a big 2025 season, with sky-high expectations. Popular podcast hosts SEC Mike and Cousin Shane from “That SEC Football Podcast” believe the Longhorns could finish with an impressive 11-1 record. That kind of run would likely punch their ticket to a third straight College Football Playoff appearance.
But while the hype is real, one surprise move has everyone talking. Texas recently added quarterback Matthew Caldwell from Troy through the transfer portal. This unexpected move raised eyebrows and sparked debate about Manning’s readiness to lead the team.
“So, you know what that tells me?” joked Shane. “Arch Manning’s overrated as hell. He can’t play. They’re bringing in a starter!” He then laughed it off, adding, “I’m just kidding. But even at Texas, they’re saying, ‘Let’s get a starter to back up Arch for this historic run.’”
With Quinn Ewers now gone, Manning was expected to take full control of the offense. He’s surrounded by serious talent, including defensive star Colin Simmons, linebacker Anthony Hill, and powerful running back C.J. Baxter. On paper, Texas has one of the strongest rosters in the SEC. Still, the quarterback spot could make or break their season.
Even Shane was surprised by Caldwell’s arrival. When Mike inquired about it, Shane appeared taken aback, acknowledging he had not expected such an event to occur in Texas’ quarterback room.
Still, both hosts remain confident. They believe the program is locked in for another playoff run. With Manning under center and Caldwell’s added insurance, the Longhorns are in good shape—if everything clicks.
The schedule, however, won’t make things easy. Texas starts its season with a huge showdown against Ohio State on August 30. They’ll face San Jose State, UTEP, and Sam Houston thereafter at home. However, the real challenge lies in the heart of SEC play, with tough matchups against Georgia, Florida, and longtime rival Oklahoma.
KEEP READING: 2025 Way-Too-Early College Football Top 25 Power Rankings
Mike and Shane believe that the defense, spearheaded by Simmons and Hill, must rise to the challenging occasion. And if Manning shines, Texas could go all the way. But the door could open for Caldwell—or another unexpected twist if he struggles. “So yeah, I like the over, and I think 11, I’m pretty firm with that. Wouldn’t be surprised if they go undefeated here.”
Longhorns fans remain hopeful for a dominant season, but the new quarterback room will be a significant factor in determining whether they secure a CFP spot or face unexpected hurdles.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!
