Kalen DeBoer, Alabama Crimson Tide head coach, knows there’s more than one way to judge a quarterback. Jake Haener was a much different type of quarterback than Michael Penix Jr. was. To add to that point, whoever Alabama chooses to start in 2025 won’t share that many traits with the now former quarterback, Jalen Milroe.
Regardless, DeBoer has seen some great success at the quarterback position throughout his entire coaching career. So, how will he decide on what to look for in Alabama’s next quarterback? He spoke with Alabama star Greg McElroy about it on the latest episode of “Always College Football with Greg McElroy.”

Why Leadership Will Be the Deciding Factor in Alabama’s Quarterback Battle
“These guys are, again, balancing the reps. Keelon [Russell] started lower, and as he earned more and more reps. We gave him those. They’re all making those strides in their ways, taking the steps. I’ve mentioned many times we’re not where we need to be. That might sound like a knock on those guys, but that’s expected.”
“There’s a progression, and there’s a process these guys have to be on. None of them have taken this overwhelming number of college snaps, especially in a game, much less, you know, with the ones on the practice field. So, we’re trying to keep them moving, speed up the process for all of them, while we’re also balancing the reps that each of them is getting. They’re earning those reps.
“I appreciate the way they’ve handled it. Not trying to press too much is the thing for them. I think the pressure of fighting for a quarterback job is probably as stressful as anything they’re going to go through. Yeah, there are moments in a game when, you know, a hundred thousand people are screaming.”
“That’s pretty stressful, but what are they doing, trying to win that job? That’s managing some level of stress, too. They’ve got to perform under those conditions. I think that’s one of the adverse situations that you put these guys in before they step on the football field in game one that actually can help them.”
DeBoer is evaluating his three potential starters, Ty Simpson, Austin Mack, and Keelon Russell, in a fascinating way. Whichever quarterback separates himself from the pack will have the high hopes of Tuscaloosa on his shoulders. All that remains to be seen is whether he can handle the pressure.
KEEP READING: Kalen DeBoer Opens Up About Building Trust With Alabama Players in Year 2
The College Football Playoff has become the standard for the Alabama Crimson Tide. DeBoer is now searching for a starter who can once again lead Alabama to the promised land. It remains to be seen who he chooses, but Alabama has some good options ahead of the 2025-26 season.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!