In a bombshell assessment that has rocked draft circles, former New York Jets scout Daniel Kelly has labeled Colorado QB Shedeur Sanders an “undraftable free agent value” despite his impressive collegiate numbers. Kelly’s scathing evaluation comes just as multiple league sources reveal the New York Giants have emerged as Sanders’ most prominent suitor.
The stark contrast between Sanders’ on-field production last season and Kelly’s harsh critique has ignited fierce debate among NFL insiders. Sanders’ draft stock appears more volatile than ever, with legitimate questions about whether he might slide completely out of the first round despite being linked to teams picking as high as third overall.
Despite Shedeur Sanders-Giants Rumors, Ex-Jets Scout Claims He’s “Undraftable”
Multiple sources have called the Giants’ interest in Sanders “the worst-kept secret in the league,” but there is a significant internal divide. While GM Joe Schoen’s personnel department reportedly advocates using the No. 3 overall pick on Sanders, head coach Brian Daboll’s staff has expressed serious reservations about his readiness and scheme fit.
I’ve studied 26 games on Shedeur Sanders and have extensively studied his character. He’s an undraftable free agent value. I am
advising teams to remove him from their draft boards between rounds 1-7.— FIRST ROUND MOCK (@firstroundmock) April 22, 2025
“I’ve studied 26 games on Shedeur Sanders and have extensively studied his character. He’s an undraftable free agent value. I am advising teams to remove him from their draft boards between rounds 1-7,” Kelly tweeted on April 22, pointing to Sanders’ alleged character concerns and on-field limitations.
Kelly specifically cited Sanders’ verbal altercation with a Texas Tech ball boy and a 2023 eye-poking incident as major red flags, comparing the quarterback to troubled NFL receiver Kadarius Toney.
“He gives me serious Kadarius Toney vibes,” Kelly stated, referencing the former first-round pick whose NFL career has been derailed by off-field issues.
Sanders’ decision to skip physical drills at both the Shrine Bowl and NFL Combine further fueled criticism. Several teams were reportedly put off by what they perceived as a “brash” and “arrogant” demeanor in early interviews.
Sources indicate Sanders has since adopted a more modest approach in recent team meetings, seemingly aware of the potential damage to his draft position.
RELATED: 5 NFL Teams Most Likely To Draft Shedeur Sanders in 2025, According to Latest Odds
The Colorado quarterback’s resume includes impressive accolades such as Big 12 Offensive Player of the Year honors after throwing for 4,134 yards with 37 touchdowns against just 10 interceptions while leading the Buffaloes to a 9-4 record. Colorado even retired his No. 2 jersey this April, an unprecedented move for a player with just two seasons on the team.
Beyond the Giants, other potential landing spots include the Saints at No. 9 and Steelers at No. 21, though Pittsburgh is viewed as the most logical fit due to their organizational stability.
Sanders reportedly seeks a franchise offering “full organizational support,” something the Giants’ divided stance might not provide despite their intense scouting interest throughout the 2024 season.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!
