Marcus Freeman’s journey as Notre Dame’s head coach has been a rollercoaster of skepticism and triumph. From early losses that fueled doubts to a national championship game appearance in 2025, Freeman has transformed the Fighting Irish into a legitimate contender.
College football analyst J.D. PicKell recently dissected this turnaround, shedding light on how Freeman overcame the naysayers and positioned Notre Dame for future glory.
Analyst Rips ‘Punchline Culture’ That Nearly Undid Marcus Freeman
PicKell didn’t hold back when addressing the early criticism Freeman faced at Notre Dame.
“Punchline culture was always such nonsense around Marcus Freeman,” PicKell stated on his show, “The Hard Count.” He called out the tendency of media and fans to mock Freeman after losses to Marshall in 2022 and Northern Illinois in 2024, questioning whether the young coach was “in over his head”.
Punchline culture swinging and missing at Marcus Freeman.
Irish are in position to have this whole thing flywheel. https://t.co/eZvwjAbNUs pic.twitter.com/vQkpGY5ylR
— J.D. PicKell (@jdpickell) May 7, 2025
This ‘punchline culture’ painted Freeman as a defensive guru who couldn’t handle the broader demands of head coaching.
PicKell praised Notre Dame for their patience, noting, “Good for Notre Dame for standing by him and allowing him to have his vision and plan play out. Direction always more important than speed”.
Freeman’s early struggles were well-documented—ESPN reported his first two recruiting classes averaged 11.7 top-300 prospects, a step up from Brian Kelly’s era, but losses to underdogs fueled skepticism. Yet, Notre Dame’s administration saw the bigger picture, giving Freeman the time to build a program in his image.
The 2024 season changed everything. Freeman led Notre Dame to the College Football Playoff national championship game, facing Ohio State on January 20, 2025, and proving his mettle.
“You watch them on January 20th, playing Ohio State with a game in the fourth quarter for a national championship. Marcus Freeman is that guy,” PicKell declared. For Notre Dame fans, this run validated their faith, silencing the ‘punchline’ narrative and revealing Freeman’s true potential.
Flywheel Effect: How Freeman’s Success Is Redefining Notre Dame’s Future
Freeman’s 2024 playoff run—beating Georgia and Penn State—has created what PicKell calls a “flywheel” effect. “Because of last year, it’s only going to flywheel,” he said, describing a self-reinforcing cycle of success.
Wins over elite teams have made Notre Dame a tougher target for negative recruiting, with rivals no longer able to claim the Irish can’t compete at the highest level.
Recruiting has become a key strength under Freeman. “The way he’s recruited, the way that he’s built that culture, the roster, all those things,” PicKell noted, emphasizing Freeman’s foundation for sustained success.
PicKell also highlighted Freeman’s recruiting pitch: “It gives Marcus Freeman more ammo, more real proof to throw down on a recruit’s living room table and say, ‘Come to Notre Dame. Here’s why’”. With tangible achievements, Freeman can now attract elite prospects, setting Notre Dame up for deeper playoff runs in the future.
Marcus Freeman’s turnaround at Notre Dame has shifted the narrative from doubt to hope, with the 2024 season marking a turning point.
KEEP READING: 2025 Way-Too-Early College Football Top 25 Power Rankings
As PicKell emphasized, “Everything you said you couldn’t do at Notre Dame, from competing for national championships and making runs in college football playoffs and winning at the highest level, you no longer can say those things because of last year”.
Freeman’s vision is finally coming into focus, and Notre Dame fans have every reason to believe national title dreams are within reach.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!
